Looking for a Magic Song Alternative?
Magic Song (magicaisong.com) and CreateMySong both make personalised songs from your details. Magic Song includes a music video with its digital song and also sells physical keepsakes. We let you hear your song free before you pay, for less.
We are CreateMySong, so we are not neutral, and we are not connected to Magic Song in any way. Everything about Magic Song on this page comes from its own website (magicaisong.com), checked on 1 November 2026. Prices and offers change often, so check its site before you buy.
Magic Song and CreateMySong compared
| Magic Song | CreateMySong | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $24 a digital song; $34 with a wooden music box; $29 with a framed photo and QR code | £9.99, £14.99 or £19.99, shown up front |
| Delivery | Ready within a few hours; physical items about 2 weeks | Usually about 10 minutes, on every option |
| Preview before you pay | Not stated on its website | Yes, a free 60-second preview of your own song, two per email, no card needed |
| What you get | A digital song and a music video to download and share; optional music box or framed QR photo | An MP3 on a private page and by email, with album cover art on every option. Premium adds a second version and a lyric sheet. VIP adds an instrumental and a photo memory video |
| Changes | Not stated on its website | One free revision |
| If you're not happy | Says it offers a happiness guarantee; terms not stated | Re-made or fully refunded for technical faults. Unhappy with the quality? Contact us within 7 days and we'll work with you |
| Who makes it | Not stated; says it creates your lyrics and a professional song | Claire and Matt, a couple in the UK. We use AI to help make the music and check every song ourselves before it goes out |
When Magic Song might suit you better
- If you want a physical keepsake, such as a wooden music box that plays the song or a framed photo with a QR code.
- If you want a music video included with the basic song.
When CreateMySong might suit you better
- You hear a free 60-second preview of your own song before you pay.
- Our songs start at £9.99 and are usually ready in about 10 minutes, not hours.
- Our £19.99 VIP option includes a photo memory video, an instrumental and a lyric sheet, and cover art comes with every song.
- We're Claire and Matt, a couple in the UK, and we check every song ourselves before it goes out.
Questions
Is CreateMySong cheaper than Magic Song?
Our songs start at £9.99. Magic Song's digital song was $24 when we checked, including a music video.
Can I hear the song first?
With us, yes: a free 60-second preview of your own song, two per email. We could not find a free preview on Magic Song's website.
Which is faster?
Ours is usually ready in about 10 minutes. Magic Song says a few hours for the digital song and about 2 weeks for physical items.
Where are they based?
Magic Song's imprint names a company in Germany. We're Claire and Matt, a couple in the UK.
Hear what your song would sound like, free.
Tell us about them and we'll make a 60-second preview of your actual song, usually in about 10 minutes. You only pay if you love it.
Start My Free PreviewComparing other services?
MelodyBolt alternative · TuneTribute alternative · Song For You alternative · GiftSong alternative · Create a Song alternative · MakeSong alternative · My Forever Songs alternative · Songfinch alternative · PersonalisedSong alternative · Just Our Song alternative · all services side by side